You were my heaven and my hell
Wish I could hate to wish you well
Well I walked away, no way to tell
If you felt the same all these years later
You got your stories, well I got mine
Maybe we can read each other's sometime
You got your answers, and I got mine
Maybe we can compare notes behind the bleachers
Just like in a past life
You and I were still in love and worth the fight
We were young and we weren't stuck in 9 to 5s
You were my heaven and my hell
Wish I could hate to wish you well
I walked away no way to tell
If you felt the same all these years later
I got to thinking that you were right
I know you got away and it's too late to change your mind
Well I got distracted, got lost in lies
Maybe we can compare notes behind the bleachers some night
Nights we never wanted to end
Nights are when I see you again
Dreaming of a different ending
Dreaming it could be a beginning
You said you hate me, you said a lot of things
But I know lately, you got to wondering
About the train tattoos and the pass of time
About my Boy Scout shirt and my rusted bike
You wanna hang out, I get an SMS
You wrote my dead name, I wrote to make amends
And then I'm coming out of Bart and I see the lake
And I wait for you, I wonder what you'll say
Cause you could have been out with anyone new
But you chose to believe that I want to be true
You were my heaven and my hell
Wish I could hate to wish you well
I walked away no way to tell
If you felt the same all these years later
You were my heaven and my hell
Wish I could hate to wish you well
I walked away no way to tell
If you felt the same all these years later