You put me on the back burner When I should've been the head turner I guess one thing that I never learned Was how to put myself first Even in my dreams We aren't right for each other Tore me apart at the seams James I'm sick of your games When you said I shouldn't tell anyone about us How'd you expect for me to go about this? Oh, James You're just the same As every other guy you swear you're not but You still have the key to my heart locked up You said your feelings for me wavered Well babe I say we take a wager If you kiss me and it feels good Maybe the "shouldn't" turns to "we should" Maybe it was stupid Maybe we shouldn't do this But I'd rather do it sooner Than later James I'm sick of your games When you said I shouldn't tell anyone about us How'd you expect for me to go about this? Oh, James You're just the same As every other guy you swear you're not but You still have the key to my heart locked up Though I still think you're a good guy I promise you this time I'm still feeling confused Though I still think you're a good friend I hope you'll make a move again I'm not quite over you James I'm sick of your games When you said I shouldn't tell anyone about us How'd you expect for me to go about this? Oh, James You're just the same As every other guy you swear you're not but You still have the key to my heart locked up