Chelsea was just like any modern girl
Known by you or me
A daughter, sister, friend and more
Out for some Halloween revelry
She'd heard of Metal Mike's mythic party
In the rural woods of Michigan
Chelsea goes as Poison Ivy
To masquerade with all her friends
The part proved to be a rowdy bash
As dusk is swallowed by the night
Thundering metal bands set the pace
Everything glows an eerie light
And Chelsea danced, and Chelsea laughed
Drank cheap wine from a large carafe
And as that night broke into dawn
She was never seen again
Chelsea didn't come home last night
I think it's time to make that dreaded call
A trembling hand dials the phone
On a cold and somber day that fall
Police and feds now work the case
And found someone who could recall the face
In that car she entered, driven by a man
And so the search for Chels' began
Frantic, fevered was the pace
A sprint against time in this morbid race
But the thorough searched turned not a trace
What could be of Chelsea's fate?
A year passed by as the seasons change
Fall, winter and back to spring again
Until that day, down by the tracks
A fisherman found a skeleton
And so we learned of her horrific fate
When they examined her final resting place
Her light snubbed out by a cowardly scum
Now rots in prison for the sins he's done
Chelsea didn't come home last night
Pray you never have to make that call
So advise your friends of where you go
And beware, the creeping strangers prowl
♪
Chelsea didn't come home last night
(Last night, night, last night, night)
Chelsea didn't come home last night
(Night, last night, last night, last night)