My first girl wore her socks up to her knees Had my teenage heart just beating right out of me I was into her just as much as she was into me My first girl she still means everything My first girl had a thick short black mane Was obsessed with Romeo & Juliet with Claire Danes She looked more like Winona Ryder from Reality Bites My first girl I dream of her some nights Alone in her house after school in a back room She wore boys underwear I had nothing to compare it to My hands were clammy cold on her skin but she didn't mind My first girl is with me all the time We went to the same university She wrote a heartfelt note to me But I couldn't lie, i was not ready To go back to what we were Still we made out on her bed It felt just like I remembered it And I thought I would return again But that was the last time our lips met My first girl i still have regrets My first girl stays in touch with my family She's got kids of her own that I have never seen I chose to leave her behind to see what was out there My first girl I wonder if she still cares My first girl I see her everywhere My first girl is somewhere out there