On a bench, dark in autumn, you wore the shadow like a dress Mixing the whiskey with questions, leaving nothing unconfessed Your body was drawn in the passing headlights, shapes unseen in the rear view mirror You stumbled onto some honesty and then, pressed on and pulled me near You said if God exists, would you take back the moments you broke the rules or got fucked up Could you find regret in a night like this one - would you wanna be forgiven? You said if God exists, would you take back the moments you broke the rules or got fucked up Could you find regret in a night like this one - would you wanna be forgiven? Are we supposed to be separate? Are we wrong to try and stay? If God exists, has it all been worth it or would you wanna be forgiven? And now that you're gone and I'm at your headstone, I curse out loud like a bad prayer We were the only thing you believed in but I let go If I'm a Christian by December, would you please forgive me, I only meant to find God to pass the time If you can find me while I'm turning over a new leaf, just know I'm looking for another place to hide You said if God exists, would you take back the moments you broke the rules or got fucked up Could you find regret? Can you let this go? Do you have to give in?