It was raining when you came in
You said, "Sorry, I'm all wet"
I said, "You don't have to be sorry
I'll help you take care of that"
You lay it all out on the table
I said, "There's no need to make a mess
We try to study, don't get a lot done
All busy worried 'bout that test"
College hall's no place for a study date
You couldn't look yourself straight through the mirror
Wasn't my fault to egg you on, I couldn't wait
I should've known you, couldn't hold your own liquor
It's a shorefire but your daddy wouldn't pay
He finds out, I'm going down undercover
You know the truth is loving you was not a mistake
But that's a lotta bad karma
I wouldn't make a bad father
Now you're saying you're gonna leave me
It took a long time to get you there
You're still a hot mess in your white dress
I'm busy trying not to stare
Oh freedom, oh freedom
Like a heartbeat can drive you mad
The thunder outside drowning out my visions
Of what we lost and what we had
College hall's such a cold place to be awake
You couldn't look yourself straight through the mirror
Wasn't my fault to egg you on, I couldn't wait
I should've known you, couldn't hold your own liquor
It's a shorefire but your daddy wouldn't pay
He finds out, I'm going down undercover
You know the truth is loving you was not a mistake
But that's a lotta bad karma
Oh, I wouldn't make a bad father
And I'm afraid that I'm to blame if you give up, Cassie
If I ever make it out of my head
You can have me
Maybe I could stick around
Yeah, I could shape up, settle down
But tonight I'm freaking out
'Cause you won't call
Cold shoulder, pulled over on the interstate
Double take, saw a little face in the mirror
Knew we couldn't tell your mother when I saw your plates
Heated seats but you couldn't speak through the shivers
You zip your jacket, try to hide your red letter A
Half mast, scatter ashes in the water
You know the truth is you could cut this any other way
It's just a lotta bad karma
Oh, I wouldn't make a bad father
But you won't call, no
But you won't
You won't
You won't call