She had me the moment that we first met Behind the counter at Al's The pancakes burned as she dialed in the radio She said "nice hair" and dropped the check L left concert tickets as a tip And she came to the show! Now she's my baby She's my baby She quit the diner for late nights at an uptown bar And we stopped going to shows When I picked her up with our favorite song all cued up She rolled her eyes and turned the dial She said I haven't liked them for awhile I guess some things will change But she's my baby She's my baby PBR's and vintage boots She can dye her hair and hide her roots She bikes to work on her single speed But I know who she used to be Now we just don't fit She was my baby She was my baby She's not my baby Anymore She's not my baby Anymore