I wonder which story you tell The one where we're in Heaven or you put me through Hell? I guess I just forgot how it felt When I didn't question every part of myself Once upon a time I swear to God we were happy Now when I look back It kind of feels like a bad dream Now blame is the only thing that remains between us (oh, yeah) Memory lane, it's a shame to think about when we were tight I wonder which story you tell The one where we're in Heaven or you put me through Hell? I guess I just forgot how it felt When I didn't question every part of myself Why don't you give me a reason, reason? You know my heart won't break even, even I wonder which story you tell The one where we're in Heaven or you put me through Hell What do you tell your friends? 'Cause you know that I've been wondering lately Do you paint me as the bad guy, the guy who's some sort of villain, baby? Now blame is the only thing that remains between us (oh, yeah) Memory lane, it's a shame to think about when we were tight (oh, oh) I wonder which story you tell The one where we're in Heaven or you put me through Hell I guess I just forgot how it felt When I didn't question every part of myself Why don't you give me a reason, reason? You know my heart won't break even, even I wonder which story you tell The one where we're in Heaven or you put me through Hell? You replaced our good with the bad, damn You replaced our good with the bad You and I, man, a tragedy You replaced our good with the bad