How'd you get a stain on your dress? Always playing in a bigger mess How'd you get a cut on your lip? Always playing with the bigger kids And I'm scared of what your mother might say Should've locked the gate So tell me why you make him so mad Hate to hear that it's a bigger plan Oh there's somehing in the water Something that I swear tastes just like Abigail Do I have to feel like everything reminds me of her Everything reminds me of the same old gaddamned bitterness And the pain that settles in your chest Round her Why'd you have to settle so fast? Secrets out and now you want it back Why'd you have to kiss him so well? Always getting on my harder self Why'd you have to let him inside? It gets the worst at night Why'd you find it hard to make friends? No one stares until the bitter end Oh there's something in the water Something that I swear tastes just like Abigail Do I have to feel like everything reminds me of her Everything reminds me of the same old gaddamned bitterness And the pain that settles in your chest Round her Oh theres something in the water Something that I swear I don't believe in How'd you never see him Oh my Abigail Do I have to feel like everything reminds me of her Everything reminds me of her Everything reminds me of her Everything reminds me of her Everything reminds me of her Everything reminds me of her Everything reminds me