I've heard that you found a new one
I hear he drives a fancy car
And now you're always running round with your new friends
Even though we said we'd always hate them
We did, we did
And I hear that he's no romantic
But still gets along with your mom
While you're running around with your new friends
I'm trying not to picture how you kiss him
I can't, I can't
I only miss you when you're with that other boy
That suddenly came around
Lighting up what I had thought would never burn
Now I'm caught between my vows of wishing you the best
While hoping for the worst
I don't wanna let go 'cause I know that goddamn it hurts
When you're with that other boy, other boy
Do you feel safe when he's with you
And do you wish he'd act like me
While every single hour that you're with him
I'm trying to pretend that it don't mean nothing to me
And oh, my mind is playing tricks now
It is making me believe that what we had was something special
What we had was so unique
While urgently, I'm trying to deny it
But I can only say that it meant everything to me
I only miss you when you're with that other boy
That suddenly came around
Lighting up what I had thought would never burn
Now I'm caught between my vows of wishing you the best
While hoping for the worst
I don't wanna let go 'cause I know that goddamn it hurts
When you're with that other boy, other boy
That other, that other, that other boy
(Damn, it hurts) that other, that other, that other boy
That other, that other, that other boy
Damn, it hurts when you're with that other boy, other boy