I used to call you after midnight It was cool 'cause we both agreed We were easy, kinda weakly Just a friend sleeping next to me Feel like we're loving but my body not my heart I guess we weren't good at keeping them apart You say you love me and the feeling is mutual But what the hell, I thought we said (Let's keep it) Let's keep it casual Let's keep it casual I was sleeping in your T-shirt With your hands wrapped around my waist And you call me things like baby And I stayed over every day Feel like we're loving but my body not my heart I guess we weren't good at keeping them apart You say you love me and the feeling is mutual But what the hell, I thought we said (Let's keep it) Let's keep it casual Let's keep it casual We tried too hard to be strong, didn't last long How could we ever resist? The way that we feel, the way that we touch Shit got me so powerless Thought we were chill, so what the hell How did we end up like this? Only one I wanna kiss, only your name on my lips Let's keep it casual Let's keep it casual How could we be so damn delusional? 'Cause it was always beautiful, beautiful (Let's keep it) Let's keep it casual (Let's keep it casual) Let's keep it casual Let's keep it casual