Matthew, why did you leave me? Right by my side is where I want you to be It feels so right, Matthew, when we're together I thought we would be united forever Matthew, what went so wrong? Now I'm singing a miserable song Oh, Matthew, I feel so bad I don't know how things ended so sad Matthew, please, won't you come back? Help me get my life back on track Matthew, what went so wrong? Now I'm singing a miserable song I'm sorry, Matthew, I didn't mean no harm I'll do anything, get Matthew tattooed on my arm