Cinnamon, a dash of spice Fooled me once and fooled me twice, I need more Innocent, wide-eyed youth Truth or lie, what will you choose Tired of crumbs I'll give real love a try Sweet as apple pie Kept under lock and key You asked too much of me Wanted milk and honey Now it's time you leave me be Cinnamon, a dash of spice Fooled me once and fooled me twice I need more Oh, apple pie Innocent, wide-eyed youth Truth or lie, what will you choose Tired of crumbs, I'll step into the light Sweet as apple pie