I spied a lovely dame, while strolling by shore Her fins glistened like starlight, to enchant me forevermore We laughed and played, till dusk came creeping through She'd hardly known, my heart was her's through and through But then she went and swam away, from me She swam farther than I could ever see Sat alone in my sorrows, as I watched her leave the shore And I thought I'd never love anymore So I told myself, There'd be others for me, there's other fish in the sea but I don't wanna go fishing, so throw em back in that ocean Cause she's the only one I wanna reel in Yeah she's the only one, I wanna be reelin in