Walked in the house at 2:00 a.m. (mm)
You watched me put my purse down and collapsed into bed (ahh)
Some stupid party's all it took (mm)
For her to smile at you and me to know that look (ahh)
Your hands all over me
They told me not to worry
About the way she touched your arm (touched your arm)
Your eyes are locked on mine
You say everything's fine
We all had fun and that's no harm
Okay
But when we get home, you compare us
I know that you wish I was Sarah
When I bring her up, you're embarrassed
'Cause I know that you wish I was Sarah
When we get home (wishing I was Sarah)
When you're alone (wishing I was Sarah)
Giving out your coat (wishing I was Sarah)
I always should've known you want Sarah
(Sarah) (oh-oh)
(You want Sarah)
Texting your phone at 2:00 a.m. (at 2:00 a.m.)
You say she needs to talk 'cause she's got boy problems
And when I lose you at the bar (mm)
I never have to wonder, I know where you are (ahh)
Your hands all over me (over me)
You told me not to worry
About the pictures that you like (you like)
Your eyes are locked on me
While I can barely breathe
I see the guilty inside your eyes (you wish okay)
But when we get home, you compare us
I know that you wish I was Sarah
When I bring her up, you're embarrassed
'Cause I know that you wish I was Sarah
When we get home (wishing I was Sarah)
When you're alone (wishing I was Sarah)
Giving out your coat (wishing I was Sarah)
I always should've known you want Sarah
Giving out your coat
I know you wanna get her alone
I know what I'll find on your phone, so just know
If you wonder if I love you, I don't
When we get home, you compare us
I know that you wish I was Sarah
When I bring her up, you're embarrassed
'Cause I know that you wish I was Sarah (you wish I was)
When we get home (wishing I was Sarah)
When you're alone (wishing I was Sarah)
Giving out your coat (wishing I was Sarah)
I always should've known you want Sarah
Sarah
Sarah