I was illegally parked in the handicap spot
To see you smile
Was it more than just the way we laughed
Or was it something else?
How did it come to this
You were tall and I was short as shit
Couldn't think of another plan
Couldn't even stay for Peter Pan
I tried to pay for your internet
But you insisted on paying it
Nothing else is making sense
So tell me why you care now
Tell me why you care now, now, now
Tell me why you care now, now
Yeah
Tell me why you care now, now, now
Tell me why you care now, now
Each day I roll out of bed
I'm sober you mess with my head
I don't even care what you said
In the checkout line with a box of eggs
What do you do after six
With those problems that Tinder can't fix
I wanna talk for a while
But you always act like such a child
I'm so done with the pain
The thought of love, it hurts my brain
I told you never again
Then you came back
So tell me why you care now
Tell me why you care now, now, now
Tell me why you care now, now
Yeah
Tell me why you care now, now, now
Tell me why you care now, now
I never could tell what you thought was right
You held the bait out, all I did was bite
Wanting to love you and hold you tight
I will always remember him there that night
Tell me why you care now, now, now
Tell me why you care now, now
Yeah
Tell me why you care now, now, now
Tell me why you care now, now
I never could tell what you thought was right
You held the bait out, all I did was bite
Wanting to love you and hold you tight
I will always remember him there that night