Told myself "I told you so"
I should've listened but I got caught up in those eyes
Didn't wanna let you in again
But then you kissed me and I thought that I could try
But then your eyes started to wander
Just like they did before
And it didn't take long, in a second you're gone
I should've known
Shame on me, shame on me, shame on me
I shoulda known that you'd mess me around
Shame on me, shame on me, shame on me
I shoulda known that you'd let me down
I let you break me
Watched you as you took my heart and left it in pieces
And you blamed it on the timing
Said you needed space, but babe you know that ain't a reason
So, shame on me, shame on me, shame on me
I shoulda known that you'd mess me around
Shame on me, shame on me, shame on me
I shoulda known that you'd let me down
You took me to right on back to fool's paradise
Don't know why I didn't think that you would cheat me twice
Shoulda known that this was coming, but I couldn't see
So shame on me
Yeah, shame on me
Oh and I gave too much too soon
Sealed my fate
Now I'm tryin' to take it back
Too little too late
I gave you my heart
Didn't need a key
Shame on me, shame on me, shame on me, shame on me
Shoulda known that you'd mess me around
Shame on me, shame on me, shame on me
I shoulda known that you'd let me down
Oh you took me to right on back to fool's paradise
Don't know why I didn't think that you would cheat me twice
Shoulda known that this was coming, but I couldn't see
So shame on me
Yeah
Shame on me, shame on me, shame on me
I shoulda known that you'd let me down