We had red eyes Almost all the time And in the haze of those wasted hours You had ways of reading my mind But all we have is history Between us now Caught up in a mystery That I can't figure out I think about those car rides Our lives sped into my sweetest memories And every time I think I'm free Get caught up in our history It's always been a mystery How you became my history We used to hate those kinds of people But now those people are you and I And ever since you've become a stranger All that's left are my red eyes But all we have is history Between us now Caught up in a mystery That I can't figure out I think about those car rides Our lives sped into my sweetest memories And every time I think I'm free Get caught up in our history It's always been a mystery How you became my history If history's repeated Where are you and I If history repeated Would we fall back in time All we have is history Between us now Caught up in a mystery That I can't figure out I think about those car rides Our lives sped into my sweetest memories And every time I think I'm free Get caught up in our history It's always been a mystery How you became my history