I was born a broken little toy That no one wanted to keep Two left feet, buttons as eyes Alone for so long, so alone Sold me off to a discount mall I sat on a shelf till you came along Cause if you don't want me then no one else should Fall in love with a stranger, no one else would But you cry all night, tell me why did you lie? When these baby shoes can tell, That I was for sale, but loved so well? Picked me up from the check-out aisle Ran out of change, got me for a five Took me home and told me you loved me Changed my name said you got lucky Take the receipt and break my heart Something in me is faulty won't you take me apart? Cause if you don't want me then no one else would Fall in love with a stranger, no one else would But you cry all night, tell me why did you lie? When these baby shoes can tell, That I was for sale, but loved so well? Sold me off to a discount mall But when we talked you said, "It's not personal." Cause if you don't want me then no one else should Fall in love with a stranger, no one else would But you cry all night, tell me why did you lie? When these baby shoes can tell, That I was for sale, but loved so well?